The Menu
Order at the counter, grab a seat and we’ll bring it to you.
Shucked to order and served on ice.
Blue Point
Our house oyster, from the Chesapeake Bay, Virginia.
Specialty Oysters
Varies weekly. Ask us what's on ice today.
Served with lemon and house made sauce.
- $14.75
12-Hour Wings
Braised, dry-rubbed.
- $5.99
Fried Clams
- $7.99
Cheese Quesadillas
- $7.75
Shrimp Fritters
- $12.50
Mini Crab Cakes
- $10.25
Catfish Bites
- $7.50
Buffalo Cauliflower
- $12.75
Fried Calamari
- $12.75
Fried Shrimp
- $12.75
Fried Oysters
- $8.25
Fried Pickles
- $8.75
Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
- $10.25
Shrimp Cocktail
Served with cole slaw, tartar and cocktail sauce. G: Grilled · F: Fried
- 3 pc$12.996 pc$19.80
Fish & Chips
- F$16.25
Clam Strips
- F$16.25
Calamari
- F$20.50
Crab Cakes
- F$17.99
Perch
- F$21.50
Oysters
- G$18.25F$18.25
Shrimp
- G$16.25F$17.50
Catfish Fillet
- G$17.99F$18.50
Tilapia Fillet
- G$18.99F$18.40
Mahi-Mahi
- G$18.99F$18.75
Snapper
- G$18.20F$19.25
Walleye Fillet
- G$18.50F$19.50
Orange Roughy Fillet
- G$17.75F$16.75
Salmon
- G$17.75F$18.25
Trout
- G$17.50F$16.99
Swordfish
- G$22.99F$22.99
Sea Scallops
- F$20.75
Mixed Fish & Chips
- G$20.20
Mixed Fish Grill
Salmon, tilapia and mahi-mahi.
- G$22.25
Mixed Seafood Grill
Salmon, tilapia, mahi-mahi, shrimp and scallops.
2 pieces of fried cod, splashed with tartar sauce and hot sauce. Served on a toasted bun.
- $7.75
Just a Sandwich
- $11.25
Make it a Platter
Our famous Fish Sandwich served with fries and cole slaw.
- $8.50
Milton Sandwich
Make it a Milton: dressed with house made cole slaw.
- $11.75
Milton Platter
The Milton, with fries and cole slaw.
Served with cole slaw.
- $15.25
Coastal Shrimp Salad Roll
Housemade shrimp salad dressed lightly in an herby citrus mayonnaise dressing and served on a toasted brioche roll with lettuce and tomato.
- $11.99
Salmon
- $12.99
Mahi-Mahi
- $12.99
Snapper
- $13.50
Shrimp
- $14.25
Crab Cake
- $10.50
Clam
- $14.75
Oyster
T: Taco · P: Plate. Choose your style — Original: fresh pico de gallo, white and hot sauce. Tio Chico: Castillo's fresh papaya salsa, fresh cilantro and hot sauce.
- T$7.80P$11.90
Fried Cod
- T$7.80P$11.90
Fried Calamari
- T$7.80P$11.90
Cauliflower
- T$7.90P$12.20
Tilapia
- T$8P$12.80
Shrimp
- T$8.70P$14
Salmon
- T$8.90P$14
Snapper
- T$8.90P$14.40
Mahi-Mahi
- T$9P$14.50
Walleye
Served with fries and cole slaw. Stuffed with shredded cabbage, fresh salsa, cheddar cheese, white sauce and hot sauce. We'll make any burrito as spicy as you like!
- $13.25
Fried Cod
- $14.99
Calamari
- $15.99
Salmon
- $15.99
Mahi-Mahi
- $16.25
Garlic Shrimp
Served with fries, cole slaw, tartar and cocktail sauce.
- $17.99
Tin Fish Combo
- $17.50
Fish & Shrimp
- $15.25
Fish & Clams
- $19.10
Fish & Oysters
- $16.99
Fish & Chicken
- $19.10
Fish, Shrimp & Crab Cake
Served with oyster crackers.
- Cup$5.50Bowl$7
New England Clam Chowder
- $4.60$10.50
House Salad
- $6.15$11.50
Caesar Salad
- $18.75
Grilled Fish Salad
Your choice of fish.
- $15.25
Chicken on Salad
- $18.75
Shrimp on Salad
Served with fries and cole slaw.
- 5 pc$11.2510 pc$18.15
Chicken Tenders
- $8
Chicken Taco
- $12.75
Chicken Taco Plate
- $13.75
Chicken Sandwich
Served with fries and cole slaw.
- $11.99
Hamburger
- $13.50
Cheeseburger
- $14.75
Bacon Cheeseburger
- $4.35$7.25
Fries
- $5$7.75
Onion Rings
Fresh cut.
- $5$7.75
Chips & Salsa (Diva’s)
- $1.40$3.30
Cole Slaw
- $3.99$3.99
Teriyaki Broccoli
- $0$5.25
Freshly Crafted In-House Side
For kids 10 and under, please. Served with applesauce.
- $4.99
Quesadilla
- $6.80
Basket of Kid’s Choice
Chicken nuggets, fish pieces or popcorn shrimp.
- $8.99
Hamburger & Fries
- $9.75
Cheeseburger & Fries
- $8.75
2-Piece Fish & Chips
- $9.50
3-Piece Chicken Tenders & Fries
- $1.80
Applesauce
Coconut Mojito
Coconut Captain Morgan, coconut cream, mint, lime juice, soda
Pear Cognac Sour
Hennessy, pear liqueur, apple nectar, lemon juice, Fee Foam
Lemon Drops — Now on Tap
Fresh muddled lemon, Deep Eddy Lemon vodka, sugared rim
Russian Ginger
Absolut, Kahlúa, gingerbread simple, cream
Cranberry Mule
Deep Eddy Cranberry, ginger beer, lime juice
Dumpling
Rabbit Hole, apple cider, bitters, simple
Blood Orange Jalapeño Margarita
House-infused jalapeño tequila, Cointreau, blood orange and lime juice, Tajín rim
- Sauvignon Blanc
- Chardonnay
- Merlot
- Rosé
- Cabernet
- Pinot Noir
- Pinot Grigio
- White Zinfandel
- Moscato
- Riesling
- Prosecco
- Red Blends
Plus seasonal offerings — ask what's pouring.
- Budweiser
- Bud Light
- Miller Lite
- Blue Moon
- Angry Orchard
- Guinness Draught
- Heineken
- Corona Extra
- Corona Light
- Modelo Oro
- Modelo Especial
- Negra Modelo
Consuming raw or undercooked meat, seafood, poultry, raw eggs or shellfish may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially for vulnerable people.
Prices and availability can change with the catch — the board at the counter is always right.